It’s incredible that Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp exists at all. The Netflix series consists of eight episodes of inspired absurdity with a star-studded cast that other comedies could only dream of obtaining. This may have only been possible given the future success of the original film’s cast: Amy Poehler, Bradley Cooper, Paul Rudd, Elizabeth Banks, Jon Benjamin…all were still up-and-coming at the time, but are huge draws in 2015. Alongside the more established cast members at the time, including Janeane Garofalo, David Hyde Pierce, Christopher Meloni, Molly Shannon, and most of the cast of The State, Wet Hot American Summer’s cult status has only grown with the success of its actors.
To see all of these actors return with a whole slate of new big-name cameos speaks to the reverence these comic actors have to the original movie. Still, working around so many people’s busy schedules is incredibly difficult (see: season 4 of Arrested Development). Somehow Wet Hot American Summer manages its star availability in a way that it is invisible to the viewer. Like the movie, there really isn’t a central plot to the series, just a vast number of subplots that interweave from time-to-time. Since Wet Hot American Summer feels like it can jump around freely to whatever weird thing it feels like doing, it’s completely fine if we don’t check in on every character in every episode.